
Would a National Tribunal Make RERA Appeals More Consistent?
Photo: Saidul Islam Bokul / wordpress via Openverse (CC0)
On November 12, the Forum for People's Collective Efforts presented proposals to Cabinet Secretariat officials seeking changes to India's real estate homebuyer protection law (Hindustan Times).
FPCE president Abhay Upadhyay and members Ratul Mazumder and Jai Pal Raheja presented the recommendations. They followed FPCE's letter to Prime Minister Narendra Modi and a response from the Cabinet Secretary that the organisation's suggestions would be looked into.
Would a national tribunal replace state appeals?
FPCE proposes establishing a National Appellate Tribunal for Real Estate, or NATRE, in Delhi to replace state-level appellate tribunals (ETCFO.com). Appeals against NATRE decisions would lie directly with the Supreme Court, and the proposed body would hear appeals against orders made by real estate regulatory authorities and adjudicating officers.
The association cited the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal and the National Green Tribunal as models for a single national forum. It also proposed virtual benches according to caseload, so buyers would not have to travel to Delhi, and appointment of the chairperson and members by the Central Government based on the recommendation of a judicially led selection committee.
FPCE said state appellate tribunals have faced vacancies and inadequate staffing, with some unable to function because they lack a quorum. It also said the same central RERA provision is interpreted differently between states, producing inconsistent buyer protection.
"Over the past decade, we have repeatedly raised concerns at the forums available to us because that protection remains inadequate." — Abhay Upadhyay, FPCE president
What would change for agreements and cancellations?
FPCE's proposals would move the Agreement for Sale into a schedule under Section 13(2) of RERA and make its terms legally binding. Under the current framework, state governments prescribe the agreement's format through rules, which FPCE says allows developers to include clauses that dilute homebuyer protections.
| Before | After |
|---|---|
| State-level appellate tribunals hear RERA appeals | NATRE in Delhi hears appeals, with direct appeals to the Supreme Court |
| State rules prescribe the Agreement for Sale format | The agreement is included in RERA and becomes legally binding |
| Section 18 primarily addresses developer defaults and provides no adequate personal exit | Buyers cancelling within one year receive a full refund within one month; later cancellations receive the full amount plus interest at the State Bank of India savings account rate |
| Compensation can require individual complaints and lengthy proceedings | Compensation is automatic for delayed or deficient projects |
The cancellation proposal covers buyers facing personal or financial circumstances, including job loss or the death of an earning family member. FPCE also proposed that cancellation within one year of booking must carry a full refund within one month.
The broader package proposes automatic compensation for allottees affected by project delays or deficiencies, without requiring each buyer to file a complaint or undergo lengthy proceedings.
How would regulatory accountability change?
FPCE has called for regular audits of state real estate regulatory authorities, independent scrutiny of a sample of their orders and publication of the audit findings (The Economic Times). The association said these measures would make the authorities more accountable under RERA (ETRealty.com).
It has also proposed separating real estate promotion and development from homebuyer protection. Under the suggested framework, promotion would remain with the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs and development agencies, while a dedicated Real Estate Homebuyer Protection Act would govern consumer protection.
Separately, the association's letter to the Prime Minister identified unenforced orders as an ongoing concern. It also recommended re-enacting or renaming RERA as the Real Estate Homebuyer Protection Act.
Which buyer protections would change?
Readers can check the following areas when reviewing current off-plan documentation and project information:
- The wording of the Agreement for Sale, particularly clauses that FPCE says may weaken RERA protections.
- The booking date and payment record, which are central to the proposed one-year refund window.
- Delays, deficiencies and compensation procedures, since FPCE proposes automatic compensation rather than an individual complaint process for every affected buyer.
- The state regulator and appellate forum involved in any dispute, given the proposal to replace state-level tribunals with NATRE.
The most concrete figure in the proposals is the refund timetable: cancellation within one year of booking would produce a full refund within one month.
Read more
- ₹210 Crore Funding Set for Raymond Realty Redevelopment
- Platinum Corp Commits ₹260 Crore to Four Mumbai Residential Projects
- 2026 GRESB: MPACT and Singapore Land Top Standing-Investments Rankings
Sources
- Homebuyers' body FPCE seeks national appellate tribunal for real estate, similar to NCLAT, NGT — realty.economictimes.indiatimes.com, 2026-11-16
- Homebuyers' body FPCE seeks national real estate ... — hindustantimes.com, 2026-11-15
- FPCE Calls for National Appellate Tribunal for Real Estate ... — cfo.economictimes.indiatimes.com, 2026-11-16
- FPCE proposes national realty appellate tribunal, statutory ... — m.economictimes.com, 2026-11-15



